The difference between dog shit, and Halo 3 and Halo Reach, is that they're considerably more enjoyable. Rather than dog shit, where there isn't a good number of people who enjoy it. There is a very good number of people who enjoy the game, a lot. It isn't a very good analogy. It's not the same logic. There are aspects of Halo Reach and Halo 3 that I like more than Halo 2 and Halo CE, and there are also aspects from Halo CE and Halo 2 that I like more than Halo Reach and Halo 3. Some of these aspects weigh out others, determining mine, or other peoples opinion.

Also, I'm sure that there are people out there who do enjoy eating dog shit more than filet mignon, some people do crazy stuff.

Hard to choose going somewhere between H1 and H2

Forever a CE fanboy.

Halo1- Best Story
Halo2- Best maps
Halo3- Best Gameplay

If i give this a fusion would arise H2 imo. So Definitely H2, one love.

But to be fair Halo CE was just an incredible pioneer in the world of games.
So that game has the most respect from me, of all Halo´s what has been made so far.

Its just amazing what that title has built.

campaign - ODST
multiplayer - H2

Whatever i say will sound stupid because this is my first post, so what can i say?

Hey i'm like, behind you and stuff.

halo 1 is best btw

Hey i'm like, behind you and stuff.

Either Halo 2, or Halo 1 for me.

The older the better. Thus has it been, thus shall it be.

I enjoy playing halo 2 the most but I prefer watching halo 3.

although halo 2 is probably the best game I think halo 3 is a really close 2nd

haloce was before my time I only ever played campaign and like 1 lan